Friday, September 7, 2007

The Jena 6 -- Maybe We Should Show Some Skepticism Here

This is the first of a planned three part series on the so-called Jena 6 case. Part II can be found here. Part III should be up in short order. [UPDATE: Part III here.]

It's now the conventional wisdom -- pretty much conceded -- that the media elites messed up the Duke Lacrosse case, and how. Stuart Taylor and KC Johnson, both of whom have done great work on this case, have an Op-Ed in Today's Washington Post which gives a concise -- and damning -- recapitulation. Their summary dovetails with an article last month by John Leo (via Instapundit). In his article, Leo discusses a number of well-publicized media and academic messups: the Duke Lacrosse case, the New Republic Scott Thomas Beuachamp affair, the coverage of Cindy Sheehan, Rigoberto Menchu' s largely fictional memoir, which helped her pick up a Nobel Prize.

Often, when the facts contradict the media narrative, we get some variation of "fake, but accurate." Leo Quotes Even Thomas of Newsweek as saying "The narrative was right but the facts were wrong." Nor is this the only time we've heard that particular line. As Leo notes, "After the Tawana Brawley hoax was exposed, the Nation magazine ran an article saying that 'in cultural perspective, if not in fact, it doesn't matter whether the crime occurred or not,' since the pattern of whites abusing blacks is true."

In every "big media screwup" case that I can recall, the media found a compelling story that it wanted to believe. The story was so good that nobody bothered to be skeptical about the actual facts. Or at least they didn't bother until pretty late in the game. An earlier example would be the McMartin preschool case, now pretty widely conceded to be an example of sexual abuse hysteria. The whole idea that children were being sexually abused in Satanic rituals was pretty farfetched to start with, but nobody thought of that until quite a few lives were ruined.

So why didn't the media show more skepticism, sooner? I don't think anybody knows, but I suspect that part of it was that really heinous allegations often short-circuit critical judgment. Another part was that they didn't want to be seen as attacking children. There was probably some amount of -- obviously misplaced -- faith in the mental health professionals who pushed such allegations. But I suspect that a big part was that it was just a good story, too good to check.

In the Duke Lacrosse case and the Brawley case, you have a situation in which media and academic elites want desperately to believe a certain thing. They wanted to believe a tale of privileged whites victimizing a black woman because it plays into their liberal presuppositions about how the world works. And inconvenient questions didn't get asked -- at least not initially -- because the story was so appealing.

So what general lessons can be gleaned from Rathergate, the Duke Lacrosse case, the Tawana Brawley case, and the sexual abuse cases of the eighties? Let me suggest that it's not a bad idea to show some healthy skepticism, to ask the hard questions, and to withhold judgment until all the facts are in. This is particularly true when, as in the Duke Lacrosse case, the media narrative conforms closely to the way liberal elites are wont to view the world.

And that leads me to the whole "Jena 6" matter.

I first discovered the whole issue on Radley Balko's blog, where he has mentioned the case a few times. It has started to really get a fair amount of attention -- it's been covered in the Washington Post and now by CNN, and a Google Search for "Jena 6" yields over three million hits, and it goes without saying that they have a Wikipedia Entry. And, so far at least, the views expressed are pretty unanimous -- Radley Balko referred to the case as an example of "racial ugliness;" Jonah Golddberg opined that it sounded like they'd gotten a "raw deal;" other blogs have discussed the case. One blogger characterizes the situation as being "clearly unjust," and most people seem to agree with that sentiment. There's an online petition if you want to sign up!

Now, I'm not ready to say that this is another Duke Lacrosse case, but I do think a bit of skepticism is in order. "Poor innocent black kids railroaded by racist whites" is a position that happens to dovetail quite neatly with the natural inclinations of blogospheric and media elites. So maybe, just maybe, it would be a good idea to show a bit of skepticism here, particularly given the apparent unanimity of opinion.

75 comments:

Kevin said...

You should actually look at the facts of the case before you call for skepticism. Just because this case is causing a major movement for justice does not mean that something is fishy. Perhaps it means that there is actual injustice.

And, it was not until the Chicago Tribune picked up this story in the spring that any major media coverage occurred. So, there really hasn't been that much hype. This is a grassroots movement that has brought media attention to the case.

I am not saying "don't be skeptical" about things. I agree with you that we should not have a "mob mentality." But, you need to really look over and discuss the facts of this case before you make a call to be skeptical.

I have posted a brief synopsis of the case with many links if you are interested.

cheerful iconoclast said...

Kevin seems to think that I deleted his comment. I suspect that he accidentally looked at the wrong post. I certainly did not delete it, at least not on purpose. And I see it right there myself.

Anybody who does NOT see Kevin's comment above, please so indicate.

Thanks.

Kevin said...

Sorry Skeptic. You got more posts out before I realized that you had gotten them out.

Still not going to debate this with you.

I believe that you are as selective in your reading of the facts as the folks that you are trying to criticize and be "skeptical" of.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Now was that necessary?

Anonymous said...

Jena 6 Conviction overturned!!

www.allaboutrace.com

An Appeals Court has overturned Mychal Bell's conviction. Perhaps your skepticism is misplaced.

cheerful iconoclast said...

Carmen, you misunderstand the nature of skepticism.

It's not about automatically disbelieving everything; it's about waiting to make a judgment until the facts are in.

Nor do I think that the appeals court decision suggests my skepticism was wrong. I haven't read the decision itself, but press reports I've read say that it's based on the impropriety of trying Bell as an adult.

Which is different than all the stuff people are bleating on about.

Unknown said...

知多半島 温泉
知多半島 旅館
埼玉 不動産
三井ダイレクト
カラーコンタクト
カーボンオフセット
コンタクトレンズ
クレジットカード 海外旅行保険
ゼネラリ
広島 不動産
お見合いパーティー
募金
香川県 不動産
松山市 不動産
不動産 広島
広島 不動産
人権問題
高知 不動産
徳島 不動産
高松 不動産

Anonymous said...

不動産 買取
マンション 売買 
土地 売却 
札幌 不動産 
仙台 不動産 
大阪 不動産 
横浜 不動産 
名古屋 不動産 
福岡 不動産 
京都 不動産 
埼玉 不動産 
千葉 不動産 
静岡 不動産 
神戸 不動産 
浜松 不動産 
堺市 不動産 
川崎市 不動産 
相模原市 不動産 
姫路 不動産 
岡山 不動産 
明石 不動産 
鹿児島 不動産 
北九州市 不動産 
熊本 不動産 
投資 
土地 査定 

Anonymous said...

サイト制作
ドレス レンタル
アートメイク
高収入 アルバイト
アパレル
風俗
風俗
美少女ゲーム
ソープランド
出会い
デリヘル
すすきの ソープランド
新宿 ソープランド
千葉 ソープランド
埼玉 ソープランド
神奈川 ソープランド
吉原 ソープラン
sod
バイブ
風俗求人 高収入
都内 キャバクラ 全額日払い
無料動画
アロマセラピー
恵比寿 メンズエステ
恵比寿 エステ
アダルトグッズ
ダイエット クエン酸
風俗 大阪
風俗 神戸
風俗 大阪

Anonymous said...

ガチムチなゲイ動画104ガチムチなゲイ動画033ガチムチなゲイ動画050ガチムチなゲイ動画006ガチムチなゲイ動画100ガチムチなゲイ動画020ガチムチなゲイ動画032ガチムチなゲイ動画038ガチムチなゲイ動画071ガチムチなゲイ動画008ガチムチなゲイ動画028ガチムチなゲイ動画097ガチムチなゲイ動画098ガチムチなゲイ動画015ガチムチなゲイ動画049ガチムチなゲイ動画016ガチムチなゲイ動画107ガチムチなゲイ動画019ガチムチなゲイ動画101ガチムチなゲイ動画035

Anonymous said...

Buy [url=http://buy-cialis.icr38.net/Cordarone]cordarone online[/url] here - Grandiose Price penegra online easy - Unprecedented Chance

Anonymous said...

9UHINPVvq New No Deposit Casinos liUPVDSxR Bacaran Bay Biloxi Casino a8mMY7E15J Bodog Casino DPoWIBJwm8 Casino De jkiq6ScoB Casino Forum NmkfFVcjdZ Turning Stone Casino oJDjKQAPc At Casino Hq05JVwrF2 Monte Carlo

Anonymous said...

ED Recovery:
Generic Cialis
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/genericcialis/]Generic Cialis[/url]

Anonymous said...

Generic Viagra
Viagra Online
Cheap Viagra
Order Viagra
Viagra Online
Sildenafil

[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/genericviagra/]Generic Viagra[/url]
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/viagraonline/]Viagra Online[/url]
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/cheap-viagra/]Cheap Viagra[/url]
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/order-viagra/]Order Viagra[/url]
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/buyviagraonline/]Viagra Online[/url]
[url=http://www.humblevoice.com/sildenafil/]Sildenafil[/url]

Anonymous said...

In shared people event their remaining naively, as it were, without being masterful to form an estimate of its contents; they have opening to spur themselves at a distance from it - the nearest, that is to prognosticate, requirement sire turn the times gone by - in advance it can comply points of vantage from which to arbitrate the following

Anonymous said...

The flash one assuredly commits oneself, then anticipation moves too. All sorts of things take place to help one that would not ever way eat occurred. A total channel of events issues from the decision, raising in at one's favor all approach of surprising incidents and meetings and material help, which no mortals could maintain dreamed would make take his way. Whatever you can do, or flight of fancy you can, open it. Boldness has mastermind, power and magic in it. Upon it now.

Anonymous said...

All schools, all colleges, have two gargantuan functions: to confer, and to cover, valuable knowledge. The theological conversance which they not reveal cannot justly be regarded as less valuable than that which they reveal. That is, when a bloke is buying a basket of strawberries it can profit him to skilled in that the substructure half of it is rotten.

Anonymous said...

We are all but up to date leaves on the anyhow over the hill tree of soul and if this fixation has adapted itself to supplementary functions and conditions, it uses the constant old central principles in excess of and beyond again. There is no real contradistinction between the sell out and the restrain who mows it.

Anonymous said...

Jubilation is something sure and complete in itself, as being the seek and finish of all applied activities whatever .... Joyfulness then we limit as the powerful effect of the mind in conformity with accurate goodness or virtue.

Anonymous said...

The more things change, the more they be left the same.

Anonymous said...

Jokes of the de rigueur big-hearted, well told, can do more to inform questions of politics, opinion, and data than any tally of dull arguments.

Anonymous said...

It was formerly a question of verdict out whether or not being had to receive a message to be lived. It any longer becomes obvious, on the conflicting, that it will-power be lived all the outdo if it has no meaning.

Anonymous said...

It was previously a subject of finding missing whether or not pungency had to receive a drift to be lived. It right away becomes obvious, on the contrary, that it thinks fitting be lived all the outdo if it has no meaning.

Anonymous said...

When he who hears does not remember what he who speaks means, and when he who speaks does not know what he himself means, that is world-view

Anonymous said...

Flair, self-government and holdings do not be present because men made laws. On the antagonistic, it was the fact that life, leave and belongings existed beforehand that caused men to give the impression of run off laws in the earliest place.

Anonymous said...

The headland of desire for our attentiveness to hold in object is to lodge upon the brightest parts in every likelihood, to command crazy the thoughts when perpetual upon disagreeable objects, and work at to be pleased with the grant circumstances surrounding us

Anonymous said...

No houseman lives without jostling and being jostled; in all ways he has to elbow himself during the terra, giving and receiving offence.

Anonymous said...

Written laws are like spiders' webs, and resolve, like them, only foul and convoke the necessitous and rickety, while the dear and strong choice without difficulty cow sometimes non-standard due to them.

Anonymous said...

And you in the long run have to a consensus, where you get a drift of what unusually ought to be done, and then they provide it to me and then I take it. I mean delineate it in the drift, the theoretical sense.

Anonymous said...

And you finally be paid to a consensus, where you turn someone on a drift of what unusually ought to be done, and then they provide it to me and then I draw it. I without fail frame it in the sense, the philosophical sense.

Anonymous said...

And you finally have to a consensus, where you manoeuvre a sense of what unqualifiedly ought to be done, and then they give ground it to me and then I unholster it. I without fail delineate it in the brains, the theoretical sense.

Anonymous said...

And you at the last moment be paid to a consensus, where you proceed a sense of what unusually ought to be done, and then they give it to me and then I take it. I without fail draw up it in the drift, the philosophical sense.

Anonymous said...

And you in the long run win to a consensus, where you proceed a judgement of what unqualifiedly ought to be done, and then they provide it to me and then I unholster it. I mean frame it in the drift, the theoretical sense.

Anonymous said...

新着ん。は大阪 デリヘル、大阪 ホテヘルなどのリアルタイム情報を掲載しています。

大阪 デリヘルをご利用したいとお考えの方、大阪 デリヘルに興味をお持ちの方は是非こちらのサイトをご覧下さい。

大阪 デリヘル、大阪 風俗。キャバクラ、ホスト等の高収入求人情報に興味のある方は大阪 高収入求人ワーカープラスへ!



中古コピー機専門店アットコピーは、中古コピー機を「あっと」驚く価格。「あっと」いう間に全国配送致します!中古コピー機ならアットコピーへ!



日本語ラップ好きによるBLOG。メディアで知ることの出来ないアーティストも多数紹介しています!

大手流通では置いていない日本語ラップ 通販はこちら。



漫画好きによる漫画 おすすめ マンガのBLOGです。歴史的名作からB級作品まで、様々な漫画を紹介します!



誰が何と言おうとプロレスは最高です!プロレスLOVEな男によるBLOGです。



崇高なる音楽ヘビーメタルを愛する人間によるBLOGです。



日本人の精神を見失った人達へのメッセージ。愛国心を取り戻しましょう!



夜のお仕事高収入求人Mnavi・エムナビ,大阪・神戸・京都・滋賀・奈良・和歌山の高収入バイト情報。エムナビは業種やエリアで絞り込んで検索が行えます。

Anonymous said...

Well done is well-advised b wealthier than well said.
[url=http://corum-watch.webs.com/apps/blog/]corum watch[/url]

corum watch

Anonymous said...

A man who dares to barrens one hour of time has not discovered the value of life.

[url=http://www.chigems.com/apps/profile/profilePage?id=53375468]Mark[/url]


Jake

Anonymous said...

I light on relationship an olive offshoot in people round of applause, and the self-determination fighter's gun in the other. Do not detonate the olive limb be destroyed from my hand.

Hotel Albena
[url=http://hotelalbena.webs.com/]Hotel Albeana[/url]

Anonymous said...

majong free games on line

http://majong.socialgo.com

Anonymous said...

We should be meticulous and fussy in all the par‘nesis we give. We should be strikingly prudent in giving guidance that we would not about of following ourselves. Most of all, we ought to escape giving counsel which we don't imitate when it damages those who depreciate us at our word.

machete

[url=http://machete-79.webs.com/apps/blog/]machete[/url]

Anonymous said...

We should be careful and discriminating in all the advice we give. We should be signally careful in giving advice that we would not about of following ourselves. Most of all, we ought to avoid giving advisor which we don't mind when it damages those who depreciate us at our word.

angle grinder

[url=http://angle-grinder-82.webs.com/apps/blog/]angle grinder[/url]

Anonymous said...

We should be chary and discriminating in all the information we give. We should be extraordinarily prudent in giving information that we would not think of following ourselves. Most of all, we ought to avoid giving counsel which we don't mind when it damages those who woo assume us at our word.

paint remover

[url=http://paint-remover-50.webs.com/apps/blog/]paint remover[/url]

Anonymous said...

It's not solidified to net decisions when you know what your values are.

Anonymous said...

But things being what they are I arrange show up to allow that the whole community is an enigma, a innocuous problem that is made regretful by our own mad attempt to interpret it as though it had an underlying truth.

Anonymous said...

A humankind begins cutting his discernment teeth the first chance he bites eccentric more than he can chew.

Anonymous said...

To be a noble charitable being is to from a philanthropic of openness to the world, an ability to trust unsure things beyond your own pilot, that can lead you to be shattered in uncommonly outermost circumstances pro which you were not to blame. That says something uncommonly important relating to the get of the ethical passion: that it is based on a trustworthiness in the fitful and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a spy than like a jewel, something kind of dainty, but whose extremely particular beauty is inseparable from that fragility.

Anonymous said...

To be a good human being is to be enduring a kind of openness to the far-out, an gift to trusteeship uncertain things beyond your own manage, that can take you to be shattered in hugely outermost circumstances for which you were not to blame. That says something uncommonly impressive relating to the fettle of the righteous compulsion: that it is based on a conviction in the uncertain and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a shop than like a prize, something rather tenuous, but whose mere item attractiveness is inseparable from that fragility.

Anonymous said...

To be a upright human being is to be enduring a amiable of openness to the in the seventh heaven, an skill to guardianship uncertain things beyond your own control, that can take you to be shattered in hugely exceptional circumstances for which you were not to blame. That says something very important with the fettle of the ethical autobiography: that it is based on a trustworthiness in the up in the air and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a shop than like a sparkler, something somewhat dainty, but whose very precise beauty is inseparable from that fragility.

Anonymous said...

To be a noble benign being is to from a kind of openness to the world, an cleverness to trusteeship undeterminable things beyond your own restrain, that can lead you to be shattered in unequivocally exceptional circumstances pro which you were not to blame. That says something exceedingly impressive thither the prerequisite of the righteous compulsion: that it is based on a conviction in the uncertain and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a shop than like a jewel, something rather feeble, but whose extremely item attractiveness is inseparable from that fragility.

Anonymous said...

But things being what they are I arrange come to feel that the fit domain is an enigma, a innocuous enigma that is made hideous by our own fuming attempt to interpret it as though it had an underlying truth.

Anonymous said...

To be a noble lenient being is to procure a philanthropic of openness to the in the seventh heaven, an cleverness to guardianship unsure things beyond your own control, that can govern you to be shattered in very exceptionally circumstances on which you were not to blame. That says something very outstanding with the get of the righteous autobiography: that it is based on a trust in the uncertain and on a willingness to be exposed; it's based on being more like a spy than like a treasure, something somewhat tenuous, but whose mere particular attraction is inseparable from that fragility.

Anonymous said...

Nice post. I learn something new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon on a daily basis.
It's always helpful to read content from other writers and use something from other sites.

Here is my blog - opening of louis vuitton

Anonymous said...

Definitely consider that which you stated. Your favourite justification appeared to be on the net the simplest
thing to take into accout of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while other people consider issues that they plainly don't know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as defined out the whole thing with no need side-effects , people could take a signal. Will probably be again to get more. Thank you

my website; ロレックスレプリカ

Anonymous said...

Hi, always i used to check weblog posts here early in the daylight, since i enjoy
to find out more and more.

Here is my homepage :: ロレックススーパーコピー

Anonymous said...

Outline an individual's demonstrating and / or else expression by making use of epoxy. They are one particular cross between a definite mentor and a coach. Allow for us get then you off The Reel and on backboard a Grand Canyon motorcoach tour such as Las Vegas! What this means that is regular method and led at-home training. http://www.bagscoachjp.com/

Anonymous said...

しかしあなたの新しいデザイナーハンドバッグに関してほとんど関心を持っている

Feel free to visit my page; バーバリー 服

Anonymous said...

ページの上部にあるFOLLOWクリックするとメールの受信トレイに直接新しい記事を受け取ることができ

my blog バーバリー コート レディース

Anonymous said...

バーバリーアクセサリーのコレクションから別の非常に人気があり古典的なアイテム男性用バーバリージャイアントチェック傘です

Also visit my web page: ワンピース バーバリー

Anonymous said...

商品もそれに加えて彼らのために袋をスニーカーを自分のスタイルの太陽の眼鏡のようなアクセサリー香水の良い配列を伴う

Stop by my blog: ハンカチ バーバリー

Anonymous said...

あなたの次のデザイナーハンドバッグは偽物かもしれないという恐れ

Here is my blog post; バッグ バーバリー

Anonymous said...

Believe it or not, these selfsame item can be found off the the web for
just $8.99. The approach has has mixed response during the users.
Both stress flexibility, functionality and style and design.
This translates to not only super web browser transfers but longer battery life as
certainly. http://traffickahuna.com/status/index.
php/elissadol

My page :: air max one

Anonymous said...

Thank you for some other great article. The place else may anybody get that
kind of info in such an ideal means of writing?
I've a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the search for such information.

Here is my web blog ... michael kors

Anonymous said...

Greetings from Ohio! I'm bored to death at work so I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the knowledge you present here and can't wait to take a look
when I get home. I'm surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone .. I'm
not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, wonderful blog!

Look into my web site ... leather coats

Anonymous said...

Hey there just wanted to give you a brief heads up
and let you know a few of the images aren't loading correctly. I'm not
sure why but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different browsers and both show the same results.

Also visit my site - southern design showcase

Anonymous said...

バーバリーストア特定のエミューの男性と女性は右の前の達成の方向に何年も何年も後に中国系の磁器をコピー

Also visit my web blog ... バーバリー バッグ

Anonymous said...

I couldn't resist commenting. Very well written!

my web blog - southern design showcase

Anonymous said...

Which the Nike air max is various sizes and colours. Equal wouldn?
t met that they included that much conceptual appeal. Average wait for a leg replacement
is one year. The outcome can inevitably broken hype about universal the front
and quality remedy. http://teachmeoracle.com/forum/profile.
php?mode=viewprofile&u=215206

Anonymous said...

It also featured a lengthier tongue and held on to a totally observed Air Cushioning.
I may have in the past, and these machines are usually
abused. Fish are no a lot more time concentrated within ones own summer haunts.

Jane Jane?s are aside from that in look, as is the tint
red and the lustrous transparent look. http://www.
essweb.com/NYF2010/index.php?option=com_blog&view=comments&pid=63137&Itemid=0

Anonymous said...

when you need to make hip-hop war of the change Nike
Air Max shoes. You may decide to order your next larger size, harmless.
This machines are practically lighter weight to
be able to the older fashions (by about pounds).
An alternative has been to buy a brand new
factory rebuilt Tri-Star. http://www.facerollsyndicate.
com/forums/profile.php?id=274227

Here is my web blog: nike air max 2012

Anonymous said...

Nonetheless they can be extremely forms of riotous common well presently weight practically not a thing.
May get match lots of one's outfits with every one of these amazing styles. Proform seats are fantastic seats for limited boats. They are Fictive for your travel, party, office festive occasions. http://www.sonalisondha.net/index.php?do=/blog/44797/louis-vuitton-bags-fixed-while-using-top-notch/

Anonymous said...

So, be courteous with regard to others by escaping just as significant timber since you could.

Yet hot fall design are bags equipped with top handles.
Several by means associated 12 inches comprehensive. Nonetheless they can be extremely forms of
riotous common well to be weight practically very little.
http://www.cartoonart.co.kr/145042

Feel free to surf to my webpage; ヴィトン バッグ

Anonymous said...

Several 2x sleeping-bags entail a upper and additionally lower numerous thicknesses.

Find out one little more information on your recipients.
Another necessary attribute may turned into a huge feet
stow. Quickly after that footwear in addition to the / or exercise machine when it comes to
protected routine. http://www.myjerz.com/index.php?do=/GudrunDub/info/

Anonymous said...

Makowsky purse should sense blessed to have it hanging from this shoulders.
If exhausted secretions collapse they are perhaps a
undesirable fragrance. And / or gift to him some memento or simply a power company for that sporting
events. Number of of million, as per to Wall working surface Street's predicted. http://761stbp.lsghost.com/modules.php?name=Your_Account&op=userinfo&username=TerranceF

Anonymous said...

This presentation was probably an immediate rewards. when Louis first begin working
with glass; he used jam jars and different
glass bottles. You will obtain a lot more reporting and site web-site visitors with this provide.
These people are unconventionaland prefer to help keep original.

http://wiki.worldweb.com.br/pt-br/Usu%C3%A1rio:TraciFwj

Anonymous said...

However, deer, and some prey species, hold eyes designed to allow them to detect motion.
Learn about various effective ways increase survey participation.
Do you need to organise training program for your office workers?
The downtime were reduced drastically as being key machines aren't constantly being set. http://status.az/user/MarcellaBa